The Problem Few Talk About – Until It’s Too Late
Amazon’s marketplace is powerful. But it’s also chaotic. Legitimate brands are under constant threat from counterfeiters, while honest sellers can lose everything from a single complaint. One tool sits at the heart of this tension – the test buy.
For brands, test buys are how you build proof to take down violators. For sellers, they’re the unseen trigger behind sudden suspensions, takedowns, and Section 3 account terminations. This article explains both sides: how brands can use test buys effectively and ethically, and how sellers can survive when a test buy is used against them – especially if there was no clear counterfeit involved
Part 1: For Brands – How to Use Test Buys to Remove Counterfeit Sellers
Let’s start with the brand side. You’ve spent years developing a product, building a brand, and gaining traction. Suddenly, you find unauthorized sellers listing your product at below MAP pricing. Reviews mention “cheap packaging” or “broken items.” You don’t recognize the seller name. You suspect counterfeit.
What now? Filing an IP complaint without proof rarely works. That’s where a test buy comes in. It’s a simple but powerful tactic: purchase the item, inspect the product, gather evidence, and build a clean, traceable case.
To do this properly, start by using a neutral customer account. Order the item like any shopper would. Document every step of the process – from order confirmation to the shipping label to the product’s unboxing. Photograph the outer packaging, seals, inserts, lot numbers, expiration dates, and any elements that feel off or inconsistent with your authentic inventory.
The goal isn’t just to show Amazon the product is fake – it’s to replicate a customer’s experience and contrast it with what it should be. That’s what convinces Amazon enforcement teams to act.
Once the documentation is ready, submit the complaint through Brand Registry (if enrolled) or the standard Infringement Reporting tool. Include order IDs, photo evidence, and a professional breakdown of the inconsistencies. In some cases, test buys also help uncover grey market diversion or parallel imports, which – while not counterfeit – still violate retail agreements and brand integrity.
Test buys also help detect compliance violations. A product might be authentic but fail labeling standards, arrive without safety instructions, or contain undeclared allergens – all of which are grounds for listing removal.
We’ve helped brands take down dozens of unauthorized sellers in days – not months – simply by organizing and submitting clean test buy files that Amazon could not ignore.-
Part 2: For Sellers – What Happens When a Test Buy Gets You Suspended?
Now let’s flip it.
You’re a third-party seller. You’re sourcing legally. You’ve got invoices, clean metrics, and years of experience. Then out of nowhere, your listing disappears. Soon after, your account is suspended under “inauthentic item” or worse – “counterfeit activity,” flagged under Section 3 of the Business Solutions Agreement.
You didn’t get to explain. You weren’t warned. It all started with a test buy – and a complaint that may or may not reflect the full truth.
This is common. Brands sometimes misinterpret factory variations, alternate packaging, or minor shipping damage as counterfeit. Amazon rarely verifies both sides. If the complaint contains a valid order ID and packaging photos – and they claim it’s not authentic – Amazon takes action.
If this happens, your only way out is through strong documentation and proactive appeals.
Start by gathering everything: invoices from your distributor, supplier contacts, product photos, labels, and any inspection reports. If you’re confident your product is legitimate, purchase it back from FBA yourself. Do a reverse test buy. Document your own unboxing process, label comparison, expiration date, and all packaging.
Explain this in your appeal. Show Amazon that your inventory matches brand specs. Acknowledge what might have created confusion – for example, different regional packaging or lot code formats – and explain how you’re resolving that going forward. Show them you’ve reviewed your suppliers, changed sourcing processes, or implemented stronger batch controls.
The key is to rebuild Amazon’s confidence. Show them you’re not just reacting – you’re improving. Because when it comes to Section 3 violations, they’re not just evaluating the product. They’re evaluating you.-
Beyond Counterfeit: Other Uses for Test Buys
Test buys aren’t limited to counterfeit claims. They’re also used for:
Compliance testing: Does the product include all required warning labels or safety documentation?
MAP enforcement: Is the seller undercutting pricing policies?
Product quality checks: Are they shipping used items as new?
Mystery shopping: Are they violating packaging guidelines or slipping in competing inserts?
Brands who regularly conduct test buys gain far more control over their channel. They understand what’s happening downstream, how products are being resold, and where risk is coming from.
Test Buy Evidence: What Amazon Actually Needs
Whether you’re filing a complaint or defending against one, here’s what Amazon enforcement teams rely on:
Order confirmation (with date and seller ID)
Shipping label (outer box and carrier info)
Photos of full product packaging (including damage or tampering)
Close-ups of inserts, barcodes, serial numbers, lot codes, etc.
Comparison images with authentic inventory (when available)
Screenshots of listing and reviews (if relevant)
Missing or unclear documentation weakens your case – especially in escalations. Treat every test buy like it could become legal evidence.
Final Word: It’s Not Just About the Product – It’s About the Proof
Amazon doesn’t have time to investigate every claim deeply. Their systems rely on signals – complaints, evidence, and patterns of behavior.
If you’re a brand, a test buy is the first and fastest step to taking back control of your catalog. Done right, it can wipe out unauthorized listings and reclaim thousands in lost revenue.
If you’re a seller, a test buy can be the beginning of a nightmare – or a solvable misunderstanding. The difference comes down to how well you’ve documented your supply chain, how fast you respond, and how credible your appeal is.
Either way, if your business is caught in the middle of a test buy dispute, don’t go it alone.
At Seller Appeal, we’ve helped brands and sellers navigate both sides – from strategic enforcement to complex reinstatement.
Contact Us
Looking for effective Amazon seller account reinstatement solutions? You’re in the right place! We’ve helped dozens upon dozens of sellers get their accounts back in excellent standing in record time.
Feel free to contact us today to learn more about our services and how you can benefit.
